Actionable ways to improve your creative quality

When it comes to creating ads, every brand wants to stand out, connect with the right audience, and drive results. But what exactly makes creative good? Many assume it’s about high production value, sleek visuals, or clever messaging. While those things can help, true creative quality is measured by how well an ad achieves its intended purpose. Does it capture attention? Does it resonate with the audience? Does it drive the desired action?

Improving creative quality isn’t about spending more or making flashier content. It’s about being intentional—crafting creative that aligns with your campaign goals, speaks to your audience’s preferences, and performs effectively on the platforms where it runs.

What creative quality really means

Understanding creative quality starts with one key idea: it’s not about how impressive your ad looks—it’s about how effectively it connects with your audience and drives results. High-quality creative is both effective (achieves the intended goal) and efficient (delivers results without wasted budget). A successful ad grabs attention, holds interest, and encourages action, all while staying true to your brand.

But what defines quality can differ depending on three core factors:

• Your objective: Creative that drives awareness may look and feel very different from creative meant to drive clicks or conversions.
• Your audience: What resonates with one audience might not connect with another. Quality depends on understanding audience preferences and behaviours.
• The platform: Content that works on LinkedIn might not perform on TikTok. Quality creative feels natural in the environment where it appears.

To bring this to life, imagine you’re launching an awareness campaign targeting younger audiences on Instagram. In this context, a polished, corporate-looking video might feel out of place, whereas a lo-fi, creator-led piece could feel authentic and drive stronger engagement. Here, quality isn’t about production value—it’s about fit, relevance, and impact.

Creative elements you can adjust and test

So how do you figure out what quality looks like for your brand? The answer lies in experimenting with different creative levers—the adjustable elements of your content that influence how people engage. Pulling these levers helps you move from guesswork to data-backed decisions.

Here are the key creative levers to consider, and how they can shape audience response:

• Production style: Should your content be polished or lo-fi? High-production assets can convey professionalism, but lo-fi, creator-led videos often feel more relatable—especially on platforms like TikTok and Instagram Stories. Testing both helps you find the right balance for your audience.
• Creator type: Who delivers your message matters. Established brand ambassadors offer familiarity, while new or diverse creators can tap into fresh audience segments. Sometimes, a creator outside your usual demographic can unlock unexpected engagement.
• Messaging angle: Should you highlight features or focus on benefits? While feature-driven messaging informs, benefit-led messaging connects on an emotional level. Testing both reveals which approach drives more clicks and conversions.
• Tone and emotion: Emotional resonance is powerful. A playful tone might attract attention, while an aspirational message could inspire action. Testing different emotional cues can dramatically shift how your audience responds.
• Opening hook: The first three seconds are crucial. Bold visuals, direct questions, or intriguing statements can improve thumb-stop rates. Experimenting here helps you capture attention faster.
• Call-to-action (CTA): The way you prompt action matters. Compare direct CTAs (e.g., “Shop now”) with softer suggestions (e.g., “Learn more”), and test where you place them—beginning, middle, or end of the ad.
• Format and length: Short videos often perform better on social feeds, while longer content might work for storytelling. Testing different lengths can reveal your audience’s attention span sweet spot.
• Visual and audio cues: Music, on-screen text, and graphics influence how content is perceived. Subtle adjustments—like changing a song or colour palette—can significantly impact engagement.

By experimenting with these levers, you’ll gain insights into what resonates most with your audience. Testing isn’t about changing everything at once—it’s about making purposeful adjustments and learning from each variation.

How to elevate creative quality: A step-by-step process

Knowing the levers to pull is important—but how do you apply them in a structured, effective way? Elevating creative quality requires a thoughtful process that guides you from assumptions to actionable insights. Here’s how to take your creative from good to great:

1. Start with informed assumptions

Begin by mapping out what you believe works. Maybe you assume your audience prefers polished visuals or that a certain messaging style drives clicks. Document these beliefs to guide your first round of creative development—but stay open to being proven wrong.

2. Develop purposeful variations

Create different versions of your creative that test those assumptions. If you believe polished videos work best, develop a lo-fi alternative. If you think direct CTAs are most effective, try a softer approach. Don’t be afraid to include a few "wildcards"—like an unexpected creator or an offbeat message—that push boundaries. These can yield surprising insights.

‍

[#cta]

‍

3. Launch and monitor in real time

Put your variations into market and watch how people engage. Focus on early indicators—thumb-stop rates, first-three-second viewership, and click-through rates. These metrics provide instant feedback on what’s capturing attention and prompting action.

4. Analyse and identify patterns

Look beyond the numbers and ask why certain variations performed better. Did a lo-fi video outperform a polished one because it felt more authentic? Did a playful tone drive higher engagement because it matched the platform’s culture? Understanding the “why” behind the data helps refine future creative decisions.

5. Iterate, evolve, and scale

Refine your creative based on what you’ve learned. Keep the winning elements, tweak underperformers, and test again. Over time, you’ll develop a clearer understanding of what creative quality means for your brand—and how to consistently deliver it.

Bringing it all together

Improving creative quality isn’t about taking wild guesses or sticking to what’s always worked. It’s about being curious, testing intentionally, and letting your audience’s actions guide your decisions. By pulling the right creative levers, developing purposeful variations, and analyzing real-time feedback, you’ll create content that doesn’t just look good—it performs.

It’s worth remembering that quality isn’t static—it evolves with your audience, platforms, and culture. The best creative strikes the perfect balance between brand integrity, audience relevance, and platform fit.

Better creative isn’t just about being more creative—it’s about being more effective.