Why creative quality is the key driver of campaign success

Most marketers know creative impacts campaign performance—but how much does it really matter?

Here’s the aha moment: platforms like Meta, TikTok, and Google consistently highlight creative quality as one of the biggest factors driving ad success. In fact, Meta attributes over 50% of an ad’s performance potential to creative quality alone. Yet, despite this, creative often gets pushed to the end of the planning process, overshadowed by discussions around media spend and targeting.

If you’ve thought, "As long as my targeting is right, the creative will take care of itself," it’s time to rethink that. Creative isn’t just the finishing touch—it’s what shapes how your audience experiences and responds to your ad.

The good news? While creative quality can feel subjective, there’s a straightforward way to determine what works: test, learn, and adapt.

Wait, what creative quality anyway?

Creative quality isn’t about big budgets or cinematic production values. It’s about resonance. High-quality creative is content that:

• Aligns with your campaign objectives
• Connects with your audience’s preferences
• Fits the platform where it appears

It’s about asking: Does this speak to my audience? Does it reflect how they consume content? Is it delivering the message in a way that makes them stop and engage?

And here’s the catch: there’s no universal formula. What works for one brand—or even one audience segment—might completely miss the mark for another. That’s why assumptions are risky. The only way to find out what resonates is to test different creative approaches and learn from the data.

"But I thought good creative was just…"

It’s easy to assume certain creative approaches work best, but those assumptions can be misleading. Let’s clear up some common misconceptions:

• "High production equals high quality." Sometimes a raw, authentic video resonates more than a polished studio ad. It depends on your audience and platform.
• "We can just reuse our TVC for digital." Different platforms demand different creative approaches. What works on TV often feels out of place online.
• "If our targeting is spot on, creative doesn’t matter as much." Even perfect targeting can’t save an ad that doesn’t engage. Creative and targeting must work together.
• "One great ad should do the trick." Your audience isn’t a monolith. Different segments respond to different messages and creative styles. Variety matters.

How creative quality drives campaign results

So why should you prioritise creative quality? Because it has a direct, measurable impact on performance:

• Effectiveness: Creative that works achieves its intended goal—whether that's driving clicks, generating conversions, or increasing awareness. It's about delivering an ad that resonates with the audience and gets the desired response.
• Efficiency: Creative that costs less to deliver without sacrificing results. Efficient creative helps you achieve your objectives while making your media budget go further.

Effective ads drive the right actions; efficient ads do so with minimal waste. Ideally, you want both—creative that not only performs but does so cost-effectively.

So how do you actually improve creative quality?

It’s simpler than you might think—but it requires intention and a willingness to experiment. Here’s how to approach it:

1. Start with a clear purpose

Before creating anything, define what success looks like. Is the goal to increase awareness, drive clicks, or generate conversions? Creative designed for engagement will look different from creative aimed at driving sales. Let your objectives guide your creative direction.

2. Design with your audience and platform in mind

Where will your ad appear, and how does your audience engage there? A snappy, lo-fi video might be perfect for TikTok, while a more polished piece could resonate better on YouTube. The same audience may have different expectations depending on the platform.

3. Test intentionally, not randomly

Testing doesn’t mean throwing out a bunch of creative variations and hoping something sticks. It’s about forming hypotheses and testing specific elements—like messaging, visuals, or tone—one at a time. For example: “Will a direct question in the first three seconds increase engagement?”

4. Diversify your creative—but stay focused

No single ad will resonate with everyone. Develop a range of assets that speak to different segments of your audience. This could mean testing different messages (benefits vs. features), tones (playful vs. serious), or creator styles (direct-to-camera vs. voiceover). Just ensure your variations are structured enough to yield clear insights.

5. Let the data guide you

Your audience’s behaviour is the ultimate feedback loop. Metrics like thumb-stop rate, video completion rate, and click-through rate offer valuable clues. High-performing creatives show you what’s resonating—use those learnings to refine future assets. If something underperforms, it’s not a failure—it’s a lesson.

6. Commit to continuous improvement

What works now won’t work forever. Trends evolve, audiences shift, and platforms update their algorithms. Build a regular cadence of testing and refreshing into your strategy. Sometimes, small tweaks—like changing your opening visual or adjusting your call-to-action—can yield significant improvements.

It’s not guesswork—it’s a process

Creative quality isn’t about subjective opinions or following fleeting trends. It’s about understanding your audience, being intentional in your approach, and using data to inform decisions. The best part? You don’t have to guess. Testing gives you the answers. By continuously learning from your audience and evolving your creative, you can stay relevant, improve performance, and maximise your return on investment.

Creative isn’t the final step—it’s the foundation. Build it wisely, and everything else works harder.

‍